29.05.2013

Dropped Rotor

A rotor was dropped last week as it was unloaded at new power generation facility in Durham Ontario, Canada.

Thankfully no one was hurt in the incident due to good safety procedures. The event may though highlight a design flaw in the lifting beam?
The lift begins

The Siemens rotor was rigged with a twin cradle lifting beam designed for the job, and lifted by a mobile crane. The plan was to simply lift it off the transported and place it in a rotor stand for storage on site.

We understand that as it was being lowered into the stands, one end of the lifting beam began to tilt downward causing the other end to rise. This then caused the higher end to slip out of the sling cradle and drop around three metres to the ground, while the other end landed in the stand.
This gives a good view of the beam showing how it is lifted in the centre and adjusters used to balance the rotor

The lifting area was cordoned off with only the lift crew within proximity of the lift, and they were using tag lines and keeping well clear. We understand that the incident occurred last Wednesday and that an internal investigation it looking into the incident.
One end drops to the ground


Vertikal Comment

We understand that this type of lifting beam - which is also used for other makes of rotor - is very sensitive to the location of the load's centre of gravity, given that it has to be balance like a set of scales before lifting. A moderate imbalance or shift can easily cause an issue such as this. If this is so - and I am sure some will argue that as long as they are used properly they work – one wonders why the design is not changed to something a little less sensitive? it does not look as though it would be too difficult. But one assumes that the rotor manufacturers have good reason.

Comments

Graham Humphrey
This event did NOT occur at Darlington, Ontario, Canada. This has been confirmed today with staff at the facility in Ontario.

4 Jun 2013

This type of lifting beam directly attached in the hook, is as written here above, very sensitive to the location of the load's centre of gravity. It's better to use a lifting beam with on both ends an attaching point for sling or chains going to te cranehook. By shortening the sling or chain, where the load is the most heavy,the load will be more in balance. Thankfully no one was hurt...

29 May 2013
This website is using cookies to provide an optimised user experience. By continuing you are agreeing to the use of cookies. More Info
OK